by Steve Lipman (Forest Hills, NY)
I miss my mother’s telephone calls on Shabbat, which is an unusual statement for an Orthodox Jew to make. Talking on the phone, as any Torah-observant Jew knows, is forbidden on the Jewish day of rest, for a combination of halachic reasons.
Ordinarily, I honor the Sabbath in the traditional way, not driving in a car, not using electronic devices, not writing, etc. And by praying our established tefillot, in shul, and, since Covid, largely at home, and by eschewing phone calls until a period of a few years that ended, unfortunately, a year ago.
Mom, in various assisted living and rehabilitation institutions in the Houston area, was aging rapidly, physically and mentally, as she passed the century mark, and calls from her on Shabbos kodesh became a reality.
I let Mom and my siblings know that if I saw one of their numbers on my cell phone’s caller I.D. on Shabbat, I would answer the call. I didn’t need to ask a rabbi for a psak about such an apparent violation of halacha; common sense dictated that honoring a parent (Dad had died two decades earlier) took precedence over any other consideration.
Maybe Mom was having an emergency; maybe she needed to talk; maybe, in her fog of dementia, she had lost track of what day it was (though not shomeret Shabbat, she was always respectful of my observance, and would not try to reach me on Friday night or Saturday or on a chag). Maybe one of my sisters, in touch with Mom, had some need to speak with me.
In any case, if I saw that one of them was calling, I would pick up. Similarly, I faced this challenge of what to do or what not to do on Shabbos when I visited her a few times a year – in her apartment, or in a health care facility — and she would need me (support staff were not always available) to do a task I would ordinarily not do, like turn a light on or off, or get her some food from a refrigerator whose light was likely to go on.
I usually “erred” on the side of what would keep Mom comfortable, or not upset her. I trusted that G-d would understand.
Jewish law and Jewish ethics were clearly on my side. Says Maimonides (Mishneh Torah, Sabbath 2:1):
“Where there is doubt whether or not the Sabbath laws must be violated on a [sick] person’s behalf, one should violate the Sabbath laws on his behalf, for the Sabbath laws are suspended even when there is merely a question of danger to a person’s life.”
When I went to a friend’s home for Shabbat, I would inform my hosts in advance of my policy so they would not be surprised in case they saw me on the phone between candle-lighting and Havdalah. No one objected or questioned my priorities. None of my friends, whose ages ranged from their 40s to their 70s, second-guessed me. Many of them had – or had had – elderly parents. My friends understood.
I always set the phone’s ringer loud enough that I would be able to hear it wherever I was. Not that I looked forward to a phone conversation on Shabbat … or to the reason, probably a matter of a health emergency, for Mom or a sibling calling me. But my conscience was clear. Usually, time permitting, I called Mom and my sisters before Shabbat to make sure that everyone was OK. Relieved, I knew it was less likely that my phone would ring within the next 25 hours or so.
Of course, if I saw that one of my family members was trying to reach me, I would be more alarmed. Had something happened? As Mom kept aging, things did happen. Falls. Ambulance trips to the ER. Other unpleasant events.
Fortunately, this happened infrequently. Mom and my sisters figured that whatever happened could wait until Saturday night or Sunday morning to inform me about it. Besides, I was several hours away by plane – what could I do, even if there was an emergency?
Not that my phone was always silent. Like most people in our in-touch age, I would often receive calls from sources worthy and unworthy – folks seeking my monetary donations, reminding me of the need for blood donations, trying to sell me insurance or offer me a loan. And so on. After a while, I began to recognize some of those callers’ phone numbers and area codes. Those calls, of course, I did not answer. Or acknowledge. Even during the week.
As for the calls I did answer on Shabbat or yom tov … not too many, thank G-d. Mom would call – not frequently – because she needed to talk. Because something had upset her; at her age, with her deteriorating mental condition, this could be predicted. Because she hadn’t looked at a calendar. Because she wasn’t aware of a holiday like Shavuot. Because …. the reason didn’t matter. If I recognized Mom’s phone number on my caller I.D., I spoke with her. I didn’t rush her. I didn’t necessarily remind her of the day’s sanctity; if I did, she would apologize for the call. Ditto if one of my siblings, very infrequently, called. Their psychological health, their need to share Mom’s condition with big brother, trumped all other considerations.
When the calls, always brief, ended, Mom and my siblings always felt better. I knew I did.
Mom died a year ago; her secular yahrzeit is on August 6. She was 104. In her last year or so, she became too weak, too hard of hearing, too confused, to use the phone. She didn’t answer when her phone rang and certainly didn’t make any calls. I knew then that I would not see her number on my caller I.D. when my phone rang on Shabbat.
And, of course, I haven’t seen her number during the last 12 months.
And I won’t again.
I miss seeing her number.
Steve Lipman was a staff writer for The New York Jewish Week from 1983 until 2020.